Clues In That Mysterious Radioactive Cloud Point Toward Russia

Nov 17, 2017
Originally published on November 20, 2017 10:07 pm

The tiny nation of Denmark has just three stations for monitoring atmospheric radiation. Each week, scientists change out air filters in the detectors and take the used ones to a technical university near Copenhagen.

There, Sven Poul Nielsen and other researchers analyze the filters. They often snag small amounts of naturally occurring radioactivity, radon for example.

Then about a month ago, Nielsen was startled to find something far stranger: a radioactive isotope known as ruthenium-106.

Ruthenium-106 has a half-life of just one year, which means that it isn't naturally found on Earth. It is, however, created in the glowing cores of nuclear reactors — and usually only detected in the atmosphere when something goes terribly wrong.

The ruthenium was detected far beyond Denmark. It showed up all across Europe, from Cyprus to Spain. The levels seen in dozens of nations were far too low to pose a health risk. Within weeks, the thin cloud had vanished.

So far, no nation has announced a recent nuclear incident or accident involving ruthenium-106. But some Western scientists say they suspect the source might have been a Russian research institute near the city of Dimitrovgrad, west of the Ural Mountains. The reason for their suspicion comes down to atmospheric calculations and the type of work being done at the facility, known as the Research Institute of Atomic Reactors.

Asked about activity at RIAR in the past six months, spokeswoman Anna Volkova told NPR by email that no incidents had occurred at the facility and that "ruthenium was not produced in that period." Russian atomic energy officials have previously said there has been nothing unusual detected at any of their nation's nuclear facilities.

Nielsen acknowledges that the theory of a Russian origin is an educated guess. "We don't know for sure," he says. But in the absence of more information, this is perhaps the most complete explanation for the radioactive haze he picked up in his filters.

Clue No. 1

Ruthenium-106 has been detected in the atmosphere before. After the Chernobyl nuclear disaster in 1986, the isotope was a part of the radioactive soot that blanketed Europe. The Chernobyl meltdown happened inside the secretive Soviet Union, and some of the first signs there had been an accident were the detection of ruthenium along with other radioactive isotopes.

This time is different. Starting in late September, detectors throughout Europe began picking up trace amounts of ruthenium — but they didn't pick up other radioactive elements associated with a nuclear power accident.

"We've never seen ruthenium-106 alone," Nielsen says. "This is the strange thing we see now."

To see ruthenium-106 without the other isotopes seen inside a reactor suggests that it might have been isolated chemically.

There is one very particular process that makes ruthenium-106, says Kenneth Czerwinski, a radiochemist at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. Ruthenium-106 is created as a byproduct during the production of a medical isotope known as molybdenum-99.

The world needs molybdenum-99. It's an important ingredient used in some medical scans of the heart and other organs. But very few locations actually make it. "There aren't many facilities," Czerwinski says. "There are some reactors in Canada, Belgium, South Africa, Australia."

And in Russia. In 2013, the state atomic energy corporation ROSATOM announced that RIAR in Dimitrovgrad had successfully begun producing and purifying molybdenum-99. There is a global shortage of the isotope, and Russia has ambitions of becoming a supplier to hospitals all over the world. According to a report by the U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, it eventually hopes to snag a 20 percent share of the international market.

To meet Russia's ambitions, RIAR researchers must learn how to make molybdenum-99 according to international standards. It's conceivable they might have made a mistake in that process and released some ruthenium, says Thomas Ruth, an emeritus nuclear chemist at TRIUMF, in British Columbia, Canada. "There is a learning curve," he says.

But Ruth isn't certain that RIAR was the source. He thinks that other radioactive isotopes might be present if such an accident had occurred. For that reason he thinks an accident involving old nuclear fuel, perhaps at another facility, might be to blame.

Clue No. 2

The second clue pointing to Dimotrovgrad has to do with where the ruthenium was found. According to the International Atomic Energy Agency, 43 nations reported detecting ruthenium-106. Scientists with various governments have collected that data, along with weather information, to try to work backward and find the cloud's origin.

A French analysis released last week suggested the most likely region for the release was somewhere in between the Volga River and the southern Ural Mountains, the precise region where Dimitrovgrad is located. A German statement also pointed to the southern Urals, though it said other areas in the south of Russia could also be candidates.

Scientists speak in probabilities, and none are prepared to say they know what happened for sure. But many now believe the Research Institute of Atomic Reactors is the "obvious candidate," Nielsen says. "That institute has a number of reactors that do interesting things including isotope production," Czerwinski agrees.

That being said, RIAR isn't the only nuclear facility in the region. This stretch of Russia is dotted with nuclear facilities. Among them is the Mayak Production Association, once a major nuclear weapons plant that now does things like recycling vast quantities of old nuclear fuel. Mayak has had a spotty safety record over the decades.

In the end, it's educated speculation. The IAEA has issued a brief statement saying that all member states that detected the ruthenium have also said there were no nuclear incidents in their territory, including in Russia.

Russia's ROSATOM did not respond to NPR's inquiry, but it issued a statement on Oct. 11 broadly calling the Russian-origin theory untenable. The organization cited radiation monitoring that had showed no ruthenium-106 over Russia itself, except in minute quantities over St. Petersburg.

Without confirmation of an incident or accident, Nielsen says the true story may never be known. "We're waiting for somebody to step forward and say, 'Yes, we did it.' "

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

Now to a mystery in the skies over Europe - in October, scientists across the continent who monitor the atmosphere reported detecting small amounts of a radioactive isotope. It's known as ruthenium-106. The levels weren't dangerous. But they were surprising because this isotope isn't normally there. NPR science editor Geoff Brumfiel has been following this strange event. And he joins me in the studio. Hey.

GEOFF BRUMFIEL, BYLINE: Hi, Lulu.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: OK. So what is ruthenium-106, and where does it come from?

BRUMFIEL: Well, it is a radioactive isotope with a half life of a little over a year. And that's notable because that means that it isn't really found in nature. It decays away very quickly. Where it is found is inside nuclear reactors. And so normally, you only see it when something goes very wrong. In fact, the last time it was detected in Europe was after the Chernobyl disaster in 1986.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: OK, that doesn't sound good. Are researchers worried?

BRUMFIEL: I think when they first saw it they were on edge because, remember, in Chernobyl, there was no official announcement. So actually, ruthenium was one of the first clues that something had gone wrong. But this unfolded very differently. So first off, there was never much ruthenium in the air. It wasn't dangers. It was tiny, tiny amounts. And second, the ruthenium was all they saw. They never saw like other radioactive isotopes that you might see if there was a nuclear power accident.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: OK, so what is going on? What are the suspects?

BRUMFIEL: Well, the International Atomic Energy Agency received reports from 43 countries that saw this ruthenium. And I should say it's now gone. It's dissipated. Those countries all said they saw it. But they also all said, we didn't do it.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: We didn't do it. OK.

BRUMFIEL: It's a classic case of everyone smelled it and no one dealt it. So basically, you know, there's no declaration of an accident. But many Western scientists are suspecting Russia. And there are a couple of reasons why.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: This sounds like every conversation I always have here.

BRUMFIEL: I know. It all goes back to Russia.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: Always.

BRUMFIEL: Well, actually, in this case, it literally goes back to Russia. Because what they did was they took all the detection data they had, and they took their meteorological models. And they ran everything backwards. And you know, the cloud looked like it probably came from somewhere between the Volga River and the Ural Mountains in sort of central, slightly western Russia. So that would serve as their first clue.

The second clue is that ruthenium-106, it turns out, is sometimes chemically isolated in the process of making isotopes for medical purposes, for medical imaging and things. So basically, what they think is that if there was a facility that was doing that kind of work maybe they had some sort of incident. Well, there's - there is a facility in that area. It's called the Research Institute of Atomic Reactors. It's in a city called Dimitrovgrad. Now, my colleague Alina Selyukh and I reached out to that institute. They say, nope, no problem here, nothing to see. It still remains sort of the chief suspect. But this is really circumstantial evidence. There is not a lot here to sort of hang your hat on.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: So will this mystery ever be solved?

BRUMFIEL: Well, it's no longer detectable. And there aren't really anymore clues. So I think honestly unless someone just comes out and says, you know...

GARCIA-NAVARRO: ...I did it.

BRUMFIEL: ...I did it - my bad, we may never know.

GARCIA-NAVARRO: That's Geoff Brumfiel, radioactive mystery editor here at NPR. Thanks for coming in.

BRUMFIEL: Thanks, Lulu. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.