Civil War Battlefield 'Limb Pit' Reveals Work Of Combat Surgeons

Jun 19, 2018
Originally published on June 20, 2018 10:34 am

Scientists have uncovered a pit of human bones at a Civil War battlefield in Virginia. The remains are the amputated limbs of wounded Union soldiers.

It's the first "limb pit" from a Civil War battlefield to be excavated, and experts say it opens a new window on what is often overlooked in Civil War history: the aftermath of battle, the agony of survivors and the trials of early combat surgeons.

The bones first surfaced in 2014 when a utility crew was digging at the Manassas National Battlefield Park. The National Park Service runs the site, and fortunately it had an archaeologist and Civil War expert on hand: Brandon Bies.

Bies says at first they weren't sure what they had. "Just pieces of bone," says Bies, who is now superintendent of the Manassas site. But over time more bones surfaced. The Park Service sent them to some of the world's leading forensic anthropologists at the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C.

They now lie neatly on tables under fluorescent lights at the museum's forensic lab. Anthropologist Karin Bruwelheide, who's spent over two decades working on bones, holds up part of a reconstructed leg bone to the light. It was one of the first to arrive, in pieces.

Now you can see that one end has been cut. "This is a very even-cut surface," she says. "There is no irregularity." It's not unlike a tree branch that's been carefully sawed. "You know, immediately we thought amputation," she says. "Possibly these remains were related to the Civil War." That might seem obvious, but battlefields were quickly turned to pastures or crops after the war. Anyone could have been buried there.

Eventually, more bones were uncovered from the pit, whose location at the Manassas site has been kept secret. Now the team has 11 limbs — 10 of them leg bones, and one arm bone.

They all show grievous wounds and amputation cuts. The team believes that battlefield surgeons, possibly at a field hospital set up after the Battle of Second Manassas (also known as the Second Battle of Bull Run), buried the limbs after performing amputations. Also found in the pit: the almost complete skeletons of two soldiers killed at the battle. They will be interred at Arlington National Cemetery this year in coffins made from a downed tree from the battlefield. Besides bullet fragments, the pit also contained buttons from Union uniforms.

Bies says these men were likely wounded during a charge up to a ridge called the Deep Cut, held by thousands of Confederates. Bies takes me there; it's a gentle slope that's lush with spring growth. He says in 1862 it was likely pasture, with no cover. Bies describes the battle. "As (Union soldiers) start to get closer, within 300, 400 yards, they start to receive rifle fire and musket fire," he says. "Men are dropping left and right."

Bies has brought a musket along to the Deep Cut site. He loads the original Enfield from the Civil War with black powder (though without a bullet). He rams the charge down the barrel, cocks the hammer and fires. It's loud. You can imagine the din of thousands of these firing throughout the battle.

After three days of fighting, Union forces retreated. They left behind thousands of wounded on the battlefields at Manassas, some for days, until surgeons arrived.

Bies says it would have been a terrible scene. During the second Bull Run battle, he says, "Over 100,000 soldiers had trampled, shot, exploded, eaten, burned everything. And so the water was tainted, every single house (and) barn was occupied by wounded soldiers, and these surgeons had very little to work with." What they did have was a standard surgeon's kit, with a variety of saws, and maybe some chloroform to knock their patients out. Says Bies: "If you could imagine sitting with a horrific wound of your own and hearing the moans and screams and seeing a growing pile of limbs from the surgeon, and knowing that your turn was coming, I can't possibly imagine what that would have been like."

That's one of the things the Smithsonian team is trying to illuminate from the bones and written records left by surgeons and soldiers. Many soldiers had been hit by a new kind of bullet--a soft, heavy projectile called a Minié ball. "Heavy ... and low velocity, and they really caused a lot of damage," says Doug Owsley, the museum's head physical anthropologist. He shows me one of the soldiers' bones with the kind of wound a Minié ball could cause. "You can see this right femur, high up, it's got a fracture up in the upper thigh," he says. "It's shattered, and it's a horrific fracture of that leg."

Antibiotics were unknown. Owsley says surgeons had to amputate to save lives. During the entire Civil War, they performed tens of thousands of amputations. "When you start researching that," says Owsley, "you understand what a horrible situation everybody was in."

Owsley says the surgeons at Bull Run were skilled, though. He examined the cut ends of the bones under a microscope. They reveal tiny striations left by the saws. Owsley says they show that the surgeons sawed expertly: starting slowly to set the saw teeth, then quickly through the bone, then slowly on the way out to avoid exit damage.

Bruwelheide and Owsley say the limb pit provides a unique look at the early days of combat medicine in the U.S. The weapons of war had advanced, and doctors encountered types and numbers of wounds they'd never seen. They were labeled butchers for performing so many amputations, but they had little choice.

"You think you know everything about the Civil War," says Bruwelheide, "but then you have a project like this that opens up a whole new area of history --aftermaths of battles." Adds Owsley, who's spent decades teasing out stories from human bones, amputations "were so much a part of what actually happened during the Civil War, as the only way they could really deal with those types of limb fractures. But you never see it, and here it is right in front of us."

The research team may be able to identify some of these soldiers. Owsley says the surgeons recorded patients' names, along with their wounds and where they amputated. "And we can look at the amputations that we see," he says, "and then we can look at the records and then we can begin to focus in" on their identities. Owsley can even roughly estimate where the soldiers came from, based on oxygen isotopes in their bones. Those isotopic signatures reflect where the water they drank in their lifetime came from.

If the team can identify the soldiers, as well as the surgeons who did the work, one of the questions they're eager to answer is: What happened to them? Who survived and what became of them?

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

All right. At a Civil War battlefield in Virginia, scientists have unearthed a pit of human bones. These are the amputated limbs of wounded soldiers. NPR's Christopher Joyce was one of just a few journalists given access to these bones. And, as he reports, they reveal the tragedy of battle, the agony of survivors and the trials of early combat surgeons.

CHRISTOPHER JOYCE, BYLINE: At the visitor's center in Manassas, muskets stand in glass cases alongside mannequins in uniform. A map shows troop movements and battlefield tactics, the usual kind of Civil War exhibit. But one item alludes to what happened after battle. It's a surgeon's kit with numerous saws.

BRANDON BIES: We have saws for removing limbs. We have saws for cutting into head wounds, for cutting off fingers.

JOYCE: Archaeologist Brandon Bies is superintendent of the National Park Service's Manassas site. Saws like these were used here in some of the first field hospitals for soldiers.

BIES: If you can imagine sitting with a horrific wound of your own and hearing the moans and seeing a growing pile of limbs from the surgeon and knowing that your term was coming. I can't possibly imagine what that would have been like.

JOYCE: Except he can - because in 2014, Bies excavated a unique burial site. It was a pit of limbs uncovered accidentally by utility workers. At first, they found bone fragments. They sent them to the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History to some of the world's best anthropologists. At the museum's forensic lab in Washington, D.C., bones lie on tables under fluorescent lights. Kari Bruwelheide holds up a reconstructed section of a thigh bone.

KARI BRUWELHEIDE: And what was apparent when we put all these little pieces together was this very even cut edge.

JOYCE: Like a neatly sawed tree branch. They found 11 amputated limbs. All but one were parts of legs. And there were also two almost-complete skeletons, apparently soldiers buried along with the discarded limbs. These were casualties from the Second Battle of Bull Run in 1862. They were likely wounded during a charge up to a ridge called the Deep Cut held by thousands of Confederates. Bies takes me there.

BIES: As they start to get closer, within 300 yards, 400 yards, they start to receive rifle fire and musket fire, and men are dropping left and right.

JOYCE: Shot with muskets like the Enfield that Bies has brought. He prepares a blank charge.

BIES: Pour that black powder...

JOYCE: Down into the barrel.

BIES: Ram cartridge.

JOYCE: He cocks the hammer.

BIES: Prime.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSKET FIRING)

JOYCE: Some of the wounded lay for days before surgeons arrived.

BIES: Over a hundred-thousand soldiers had trampled, shot, exploded, eaten, burned everything. Every single house, barn, was occupied by wounded soldiers, and the surgeons had very little to work with.

JOYCE: Many soldiers had been hit by a new kind of bullet, a soft, heavy projectile called a Minie ball. At the Smithsonian, chief physical anthropologist Doug Owsley shows me a bone with the kind of wound a Minie ball would cause.

DOUG OWSLEY: You can see that this right femur, high up it's got a fracture up in the upper thigh.

JOYCE: It's shattered. Looks shattered to me.

OWSLEY: It's shattered, and it's a horrific fracture of that leg.

JOYCE: Antibiotics were unknown. Owsley says surgeons had to amputate to save lives. During the entire Civil War, they performed tens of thousands of amputations.

OWSLEY: When you start researching that, you find out what a horrible situation everybody was in.

JOYCE: Owsley says the surgeons at Bull Run were skilled, though. Tiny striations on the cuts show that they sawed swiftly but expertly. Bruwelheide and Owsley say the limb pit is the first ever excavated from a Civil War battlefield.

BRUWELHEIDE: You think you know everything about the Civil War, but then you have a project like this that opens up a whole new area of history, aftermaths of battles.

OWSLEY: It's so much a part of what actually happened during the Civil War as the only way they could really deal with these types of limb fractures, but you never see it. And here it is right in front of us.

JOYCE: The research team may be able to identify some of these soldiers. Owsley says the surgeons recorded patients' names along with the wounds and where they amputated. That might allow the team to match names with bones and perhaps even find out what happened to those who survived.

Christopher Joyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.